• Link Building

Link Building Agency Checklist: 15 Questions to Ask in 2025

  • Felix Rose-Collins
  • 2 min read

Intro

Choosing a link building agency in 2025 isn’t just about price—it’s about trust, transparency, and long-term results. A single bad link can damage your rankings, while the right ones can propel your site to the top. So before you sign any contracts, here are the 15 must-ask questions to vet your next link partner.

1. Do You Use Manual Outreach?

Avoid agencies that rely on automation, bots, or link marketplaces. Manual outreach ensures higher quality, niche relevance, and safety from Google penalties.

You should always have the option to see where your links are going—especially if you care about relevance, traffic, and authority.

3. Do the Sites Have Real Organic Traffic?

High DR doesn’t always mean real value. Ask to see Ahrefs or Similarweb traffic data. Traffic = real audiences = better SEO impact.

Ensure the agency offers the link types you need—guest posts, niche edits, PR links, homepage links, etc.—based on your goals.

Confirm that the links are do-follow and that pages are indexed in Google. A no-indexed page offers no SEO value.

6. What Metrics Do You Provide?

Good agencies give you data like:

  • DR (Domain Rating)

  • Monthly organic traffic

  • Anchor text used

  • URL of the live link

  • Indexation status

7. Do You Avoid PBNs and AI-Generated Content?

This is critical. Google is cracking down harder in 2025 on PBNs and low-quality AI content. Ensure your agency sticks to white-hat, editorial strategies.

8. Can You Match My Niche or Industry?

Generic links from unrelated sites won’t help. Confirm that they can secure links from websites in your niche.

9. Who Writes the Content?

Is it outsourced, AI-generated, or written by real people with editorial review? Poor content can hurt credibility—even if the link is good.

10. How Long Does Delivery Take?

Standard turnaround for quality agencies is 5–15 business days. Avoid anyone who promises dozens of links overnight.

Get transparent pricing. Agencies that hide pricing or upsell vague “packages” often underdeliver.

12. What Is the Minimum Commitment?

Can you buy one link to test quality? Or are you locked into long-term retainers before seeing results?

A good agency will replace broken or removed links within a defined window (30–90 days). Make sure this is in writing.

14. Can I Track ROI and Performance?

Use a platform like Ranktracker to monitor keyword movements, backlink growth, and page-level traffic. Smart agencies will help you track performance, not just deliver links.

15. Why Should I Trust You Over Another Agency?

Ask for proof. Testimonials, client results, case studies, and even a sample report go a long way in building confidence.


Why Ranktracker Checks Every Box

If you want safe, transparent, and results-driven link building in 2025, Ranktracker is your go-to agency. Here’s why:

  • 100% manual outreach on real, niche-relevant sites

  • Transparent pricing, fast delivery, and no BS

  • Full metrics before and after placement

  • Guest posts, niche edits, and hybrid strategies available

  • Includes access to the full Ranktracker SEO toolkit—keyword tracking, backlink monitor, and more

With Ranktracker, you're not just buying links. You're building authority, rankings, and trust—safely and at scale.

Felix Rose-Collins

Felix Rose-Collins

Ranktracker's CEO/CMO & Co-founder

Felix Rose-Collins is the Co-founder and CEO/CMO of Ranktracker. With over 15 years of SEO experience, he has single-handedly scaled the Ranktracker site to over 500,000 monthly visits, with 390,000 of these stemming from organic searches each month.

Start using Ranktracker… For free!

Find out what’s holding your website back from ranking.

Create a free account

Or Sign in using your credentials

Different views of Ranktracker app