Intro
Collecting web data can support keyword research, competitor monitoring, product analysis and market intelligence. However, choosing the right infrastructure involves more than comparing advertised request volumes or the size of an IP pool.
Some teams need proxies for an existing scraper. Others want structured search results without maintaining a parser. A third group needs browser rendering and extraction for pages that depend on JavaScript.
This guide compares six providers across those different requirements, starting with ThorData. It focuses on publicly documented product capabilities rather than independent performance benchmarks. The order is a starting point for evaluation, not a universal performance ranking.
At a glance
| Provider | Main offering | Useful starting point | Pricing consideration |
| ThorData | Proxy infrastructure, SERP API and web scraping solutions | Teams evaluating proxy access and managed data collection together | Compare the relevant proxy plan or API allowance |
| Bright Data | Proxies, web access APIs and datasets | Organisations with several web data requirements | Different products have separate billing models |
| Oxylabs | Proxy networks, web APIs and browser tools | Teams building broader data collection infrastructure | Review product-specific subscriptions and usage terms |
| Decodo | Proxy services and web data APIs | Developers combining direct proxy access with managed extraction | Request complexity and product selection affect costs |
| ScrapingBee | Managed scraping and dedicated APIs | Developers seeking an API-led collection workflow | Check credit consumption for the required features |
| SerpApi | Structured search engine results | SEO teams that primarily need SERP data | Match search allowances to monitoring frequency |
1. ThorData: Proxy infrastructure and web data APIs
ThorData offers residential, mobile, static ISP and datacenter proxies alongside SERP API, Web Scraper API and Web Unlocker solutions.
That combination makes it a relevant starting point for teams with several collection workflows. A business might use direct proxies for a scraper it already operates, while evaluating an API for search results or another task where managed collection reduces maintenance.
For SEO teams, the SERP API is particularly relevant when search data needs to feed reporting, competitor research or monitoring tools. For eCommerce and market research, proxy infrastructure and scraping products can support collection from public web pages.
Key capabilities to evaluate
- Multiple proxy types for different workloads
- Geographic targeting for location-sensitive collection
- Rotating and sticky-session options
- API-based integration
- Separate products for search results and broader web collection
Pricing considerations
The All-in-One Platform for Effective SEO
Behind every successful business is a strong SEO campaign. But with countless optimization tools and techniques out there to choose from, it can be hard to know where to start. Well, fear no more, cause I've got just the thing to help. Presenting the Ranktracker all-in-one platform for effective SEO
We have finally opened registration to Ranktracker absolutely free!
Create a free accountOr Sign in using your credentials
ThorData publishes separate pricing for its proxy and API products. Evaluate the plan that matches the workflow rather than comparing a proxy bandwidth rate directly with an API request rate.
For example, a bandwidth-based scraper may need to account for response sizes and retries. An API workflow may instead depend on request allowances and the output supplied by the endpoint. Confirm the current pricing tier, credit rules and expiration terms before estimating a monthly budget.
Potential fit
ThorData is worth evaluating when a team wants both direct proxy access and managed web data products. Run a small pilot against representative targets to check location accuracy, session behaviour, response quality and integration effort.
Official product and pricing reference: https://www.thordata.com/pricing
2. Bright Data: A broad web data product portfolio
Bright Data offers proxy services, SERP API, browser infrastructure, scraper APIs and datasets. Its product catalogue spans several approaches to obtaining web data, from running a collection workflow to purchasing pre-collected information.
This breadth is useful when different departments have different requirements. An SEO team may need search results, while a research team needs product records or an existing dataset.
The All-in-One Platform for Effective SEO
Behind every successful business is a strong SEO campaign. But with countless optimization tools and techniques out there to choose from, it can be hard to know where to start. Well, fear no more, cause I've got just the thing to help. Presenting the Ranktracker all-in-one platform for effective SEO
We have finally opened registration to Ranktracker absolutely free!
Create a free accountOr Sign in using your credentials
Key capabilities to evaluate
- Residential, ISP and datacenter proxy products
- Search engine results collection through SERP API
- Browser-based access
- Dedicated scraper APIs and dataset options
Pricing considerations
The platform contains several products with different charging structures. Estimate costs for the specific service, target and output required. A dataset purchase and an ongoing scraping workflow are different commercial decisions.
Potential fit
Bright Data belongs on the shortlist for organisations that need several forms of web data access. The trade-off is that a wider product catalogue requires careful product selection and cost modelling.
Official reference: https://brightdata.com/
3. Oxylabs: Proxy networks and web data infrastructure
Oxylabs combines residential, mobile, ISP and datacenter proxies with web APIs, browser tools and datasets.
It is relevant for teams that want to evaluate both the network layer and managed collection products. Its documentation, integrations and product-specific services provide several ways to connect collection infrastructure with an existing application.
Key capabilities to evaluate
- Several proxy types
- Search and scraping APIs
- Browser tooling
- Integration documentation and operational resources
Pricing considerations
Check the pricing and usage terms of the exact product under consideration. For proxies, examine bandwidth, IP allocation and concurrency conditions. For APIs, review request charging, output options and any limits that affect the workflow.
Potential fit
Oxylabs is a candidate for engineering teams designing a collection system with multiple requirements. Compare the maintenance needed for direct proxy integration with the convenience of its managed products.
Official reference: https://oxylabs.io/
4. Decodo: Proxies and managed web data workflows
Decodo offers proxy services alongside a web data API covering tasks such as scraping, searching, mapping and crawling.
These are distinct operations. A scrape request retrieves a page, while crawling can involve discovering and processing multiple pages. Choosing the appropriate operation helps keep integration and billing expectations realistic.
Key capabilities to evaluate
- Residential, ISP, mobile and datacenter proxy options
- Managed scraping and search
- Website mapping and crawling
- Structured and document-oriented output options
Pricing considerations
Review how the selected product charges for the required work. The web data API describes pricing that depends on request complexity, so a basic page retrieval should not automatically be treated as equivalent to a more demanding collection task.
Potential fit
Decodo is worth considering for developers who want both direct proxy access and managed web data operations. Test the specific endpoint and output format your application will consume.
Official reference: https://decodo.com/
5. ScrapingBee: An API-led approach to web collection
ScrapingBee provides a managed scraping API with features including JavaScript scenarios, screenshots and data extraction. It also offers dedicated APIs for search and other data sources.
This approach can reduce the amount of proxy and browser infrastructure a developer needs to maintain. However, the application still needs to validate responses, handle errors and decide how extracted information enters its database.
Key capabilities to evaluate
- Managed HTML retrieval
- JavaScript interactions
- CSS/XPath extraction
- Screenshots and dedicated search APIs
Pricing considerations
ScrapingBee uses API credits. Check the credit cost of the required configuration, including any rendering or other options, rather than treating every request as having the same cost.
Potential fit
ScrapingBee is relevant when the main goal is to integrate a collection API quickly. A representative test should cover dynamic pages, missing fields and response consistency.
Official reference: https://www.scrapingbee.com/
6. SerpApi: A focused option for search results
SerpApi specialises in collecting and structuring results from Google and other search engines. Its documented features include location parameters and structured output for several search result types.
This makes it a focused candidate for keyword monitoring, local search research and applications that need search data without building their own result-page parser.
Key capabilities to evaluate
- Structured search results
- Location-aware queries
- Organic results and supported search features
- Parameters for different search workflows
Pricing considerations
Estimate searches using the number of keywords, locations, devices and monitoring intervals. Repeated checks across several markets can create a much larger workload than the keyword count alone suggests.
Potential fit
SerpApi is a relevant option when search results are the core requirement. Teams that also need broad website scraping or direct proxy access should evaluate those needs separately.
Official reference: https://serpapi.com/
How to choose a provider for your workflow
Start by defining the output your application needs.
If your team already runs a scraper and maintains its parsers, direct proxies may offer the control you need. If you mainly require structured search results, a SERP API can remove some collection and parsing work. If the page depends on interactive browser behaviour, evaluate rendering and browser support.
Next, test a representative workload. Include the locations, page types and session lengths that matter in production. Record successful usable responses, latency, retries, missing fields and total spend.
A useful cost measure is:
Cost per usable result = total collection cost ÷ results that pass your validation checks
The All-in-One Platform for Effective SEO
Behind every successful business is a strong SEO campaign. But with countless optimization tools and techniques out there to choose from, it can be hard to know where to start. Well, fear no more, cause I've got just the thing to help. Presenting the Ranktracker all-in-one platform for effective SEO
We have finally opened registration to Ranktracker absolutely free!
Create a free accountOr Sign in using your credentials
Include engineering and maintenance time when comparing approaches. A low advertised unit price can be less attractive if the workflow requires substantial ongoing repair.
Finally, review data access permissions, privacy requirements and the provider’s usage terms. Prefer official APIs or authorised feeds where suitable, and avoid collecting information your business does not need.
Final thoughts
ThorData, Bright Data, Oxylabs, Decodo, ScrapingBee and SerpApi address overlapping but different collection requirements.
ThorData provides a starting point for evaluating proxy infrastructure alongside SERP and web scraping APIs. The other providers offer alternatives ranging from broad data platforms to focused API services.
The most useful shortlist is the one that matches your targets, output requirements and operating budget. A documented pilot will provide a stronger basis for choosing than headline claims alone.

